I know my tutorials usually tell you what you should do, but this tutorial is going to tell you what not to do with a real live example.
Your website represents the face of your business and is often the first impression people will have. It is critical that you deliver an exceptional user experience or you may risk doing lasting damage to your brand.
This morning I was browsing the web looking for a new mobile and broadband supplier. I remembered a recent advertising campaign by Everything Everywhere that offer both mobile & broadband under one roof, perfect! Or so I thought.
This tutorial will show you exactly how not to launch a website and allow you to learn from other peoples 7 figure mistakes.
Video Transcript
Hi Guys Matthew Woodward here and today I’m going to tell you how not to launch a website with a real live example.
Your website is the public face of your business, just like a retail store or a sales assistant represents your brand so does your website.
With each and every visitor you get, you only have 1 chance to make the right impression and keep them hooked forever.
Get it wrong though, and you will lose that person forever or do serious damage to your brand as a whole.
I find a lot of people rush out to build and promote a site before they take the time to understand their target audience.
What happens is sites get launched before they are really ready as people are eager to push forward.
All this does though is deliver a poor user experience while failing to deliver what your users actually want and address their key concerns.
Most people that contact me are only interested in pushing more traffic and pay no care or attention to the actual user experience.
Successful websites will work 24 hours a day 7 days a week to promote your business and your brand.
They should build trust and relationships on complete auto pilot while extracting as much value as possible from every single visitor whether that’s is through an email sign up, social share, sales or simply telling their friends.
So let’s take a look at exactly what not to do. Let me paint you a quick picture.
I’m looking for a new mobile phone contract and fibre broadband.
A new brand called Everything Everywhere has recently launched in the UK.
They provide both 4G mobile phone and fibre broadband services under one roof – perfect.
It has being heavily advertised across national media with some pretty lengthy TV spots.
I had placed an order with their competition but the sales staff lied to me to get my order.
By definition, I am the perfect lead.
So of all of that in mind I come to Google and like many people will do search for everything everywhere. A see that they’ve got the adwords number one result and the organic result there. Now let’s have a look at the organic result. Say hello to the most advanced digital communications company in Britain, the most advanced digital communications company that sounds exactly like what I need at the moment. So let’s see what their video’s about. Now I might just be being picky here but I would expect the most advanced digital communications company to be showing off their technical abilities by hosting their own videos not using another company to host which in this case YouTube. Perhaps I’m being a bit picky there but as a tech guy if I’m buying something from an advanced digital communications company I expect them to be serving their own content not somebody else. So that aside let’s take a look around at what we can see and can’t really see much about five here. Nothing really and perhaps if we have a look at the shop. Fibre broadband, perfect, that’s what I want fiber broadband. Click on that, oh! well that’s not good. Orange? I’m not on the orange website. Im on the everything everywhere website. Orange shop, ipads first no nothing to do with fiber broadband here at all and I fact im on a completely different company’s website now.
So I really don’t know where to go from here, it seems that the most the most advanced digital communications company in Britain can’t actually make a website. So let’s try something else. Enter the shop that might be a good start. No no perhaps that is wrong as well okay, explore, explore is always a good word that will help me to find over information. Let’s explore the website further. Oh! I want to learn about, yes I want to learn about your fiber broadband perfect, or perhaps not. So you kind of get the general idea, and it’s not really leaving the best impression on me at all. And I’m certainly not buying into that claim that you are the most advanced digital communications company in Britain. Your website does not give me the impression. But let’s give them a second chance and head back to Google.
So last time we clicked on the number one organic result, this time we’re going to click on the number one add words result. Now they’ll be paying for every person who clicks on this and they are also in full control of where the traffic lands. So let’s take a look at what they’ve got. And as we can see here the page is loading very slowly, still loading. Still loading and I’m on twenty four mega broadband here and it took a good 5 to 6 seconds to load and I actually get 24 magnified speed tests and I get the full 24. So it’s taken a good 5-6 seconds for the website to load. Just scrolling down the page, I’m not really sure what’s going on to be honest there’s no scroll bar here to navigate and it’s not apparently obvious what to do. Highlighting over these helps a little bit. But really it’s a bit confusing especially to people that aren’t familiar with websites and navigation and things like that. This is second nature to me and even I’m struggling to understand how it all fits together.
So let’s just click on fiber broadband here. And even clicking on that is hard work. So there we go, fiber broadband, that’s what I want to know about. Yes, yes fiber broadband I’ve just told you for the third time that is what I want to know about thank you. Let’s click on explore, and now we’re actually getting some useful information about the fiber broadband and what it offers and the different, we can look at speed and coverage. And we can share the love with our family. So let’s see can I benefit, can I actually get a fiber broadband from this company. Let’s have a look at their broadband checker. I’m expecting to enter my phone number or post code and address somewhere, no it’s telling me to choose a plan but I don’t even know if I can get the plan yet. Okay, okay now we’re actually going wrong here, let’s explore again, let’s go back to fiber and have a look at what’s going on here. Well clicking that doesn’t actually do anything. Let’s try the coverage checker, perfect, that’s exactly what we want. Only that doesn’t do anything either okay. Let’s try the shop maybe the shop will help us out. Fiber broadband yes that’s what we want, oh no it doesn’t do anything either, how about this, no that doesn’t do anything.
Let’s enter the shop. Maybe entering the shop is a good start. No that doesn’t do anything either. So I still don’t know if I can buy the product. And even if I did know that I can buy the product, I couldn’t buy the product; it’s really bizarre and a bad experience. So let’s head back a page maybe I clicked on something wrong here, what’s this about okay super-fast and oh! if I combine it with my mobile service I can save sixty pound well that’s perfect my mobile phone contract is what I want fiber broadband, excellent perfect customer.
About broadband maybe that will help me. Speed and price checker. You see what I’m getting at here, you know, I actually spent nearly half an hour this morning and this is what led me to create this video trying just to find out a price on how much it would cost a fiber broadband with them and with my mobile phone contract to them. And it is absolutely next to impossible. On top of that you can’t even order the fiber broadband online, you have to call them. Now these guys are the most advanced digital communications company in Britain they are their own words. Let’s see what a competitor can do. Plus net, fiber broadband and phone break down the packages nice and easily there’s the usage there’s the speeds find out more. If I want to check availability I can do that. Enter your phone number and post code, and up here look you can clearly see this is a start of a sales funnel to place the order online. So if a competitor can do that why can’t the most advanced digital communications company in Britain do that? It really is bizarre; it is beyond me how this is being launched.
Another thing that popped out while I was browsing the site was this asking for my feedback and what I think about the website. Now this is really intrusive, I’m just learning about the company trying to find out what they offer, just an initial point of contact if you like and already they’re trying to push feedback on me which I’m not in the position to give really at the moment. So you’d think it will be as simple as clicking on no thanks. But as you can see, clicking on no thanks no matter how many times you click it the message does not go away. But if you click on take part, stray away the survey pops up without hesitation. So if you start filling this out, are you over the age of 16 yes, how likely will you be to recommend the EE website to friends or family? Definitely wouldn’t and they’ll ask you why, you’re gonna find out why. This is just really bad, look how intrusive that is and I can’t even get rid of it. I’m actually forced now to return back to Google and start my search again. It’s really a bad user experience.
I’ll be honest the site has left an awful impression on the business as a whole. I certainly do not trust them or feel comfortable ordering from them. How many other people feel the same way?
I was the perfect lead, ready to sign up! How on earth can the site fail to convert me into a sale?
In fact what it actually did is turn me cold – certainly makes the competition look more appealing.
They had the opportunity to not only gain my business, but take it away from key competitors at the same time.
From now on any form of Everything Everywhere advertising will go ignored – they have lost me forever and you can be sure I’ll be telling all my friends about it in the pub later and every time an advert comes on the TV.
I really do not understand what is going on here. I really do expect more from major brands.
They have failed to identify any of the key concerns their potential customers may have.
The site does not provide any answers to those questions and only confuses the user further.
The user experience is basically non-existent and is currently setup to do lasting damage.
It is clear there has being little to no testing of the site.
I’m going to make the assumption that corners were cut to meet deadlines, budget requirement and appease pressure from decision makers at the cost of the user.
I find it laughable that people get paid big money to produce sites like this.
But you haven’t heard the best bit yet.
The funny thing about all of this they have spent 4 million pounds on a national advertising campaign
It’s running across the UK right now on television, in press and online.
Honestly I’m not even joking they are spending 4 million pound to promote a website that delivers a damaging lasting impression.
I’m really lost for words…
So after seeing that do you think you can do better?
Remember that budget isn’t everything and that delivering an exceptional user experience is.
Make sure you put time and effort into getting the basics and foundations of the site right before any form of promotion. Certainly before pissing 4 million up the wall anyway.
You only have one chance to build a trust and a relationship with your visitor so whatever you do, make sure you don’t blow it!
Thanks for watching my tutorial! If you have any questions head over to my site and click on ask a question in the header navigation.
If you want to see more tutorials like this then don’t be afraid to subscribe in my sidebar or at the end of one of my posts.
See ya!
One of my readers John Nre brought up the site was now fixed and suggested I had recorded the video a couple of weeks ago before the site was done.
The clips that you see of the site in the video were recorded between the hours of 14:03 and 14:26 on Saturday the 10th of November.
I’m fairly sure the nationwide advertising campaign started on the 30th of October.
The issues highlighted in the video were quick fixed to an extent on the morning of the 12th November.
All of the issues I found but didn’t highlight in the video are still present. I’m going to let those ones play out though, I’ve done my bit and saved them millions already!
Please post any questions, feedback and comments below and I will personally answer them all!
29 Responses
Very enlightening! But not surprising at all. There are still a lot of people out there in big and small companies that still don't get it!
2 problems I see here.
1. A dodgy web development team more interested in bells and whistles than getting a functional site working.
2. Why aren't the marketing team checking the website before it goes live. Are they really leaving that presentation of their business to the outside world to the web guys?
Shocking!
[Reply]
Matthew Woodward Reply:
November 11th, 2012 at 10:16 am
Nope big companies just do not get it, I've plenty of first hand experience in that area.
1. Yes I agree design > function at the cost of the user
2. I can't see how it hasn't gone through a testing/sign off phase personally
Crazy world – I bet they paid at least £150,000 for that as well
[Reply]
I agree about the EE UI being a disaster…But unless the video explains more than the transcript, I don't see how your post qualifies as a tutorial. It doesn't explain 'how not to' or 'how to'. If the video does explain better than the transcript you are as guilty as EE or doing a poor job of muddling a visitor. In fact that is the case anyway as given what I have read, I feel mislead into coming here to read the post.
[Reply]
Kim Celinder Reply:
November 11th, 2012 at 12:59 am
Did we read the same headline, it say "How not to launch a website" and didn't he show us how not to launch a website, with bad navigation, not working links, only way to get the product is calling etc. etc.
[Reply]
Matthew Woodward Reply:
November 11th, 2012 at 10:19 am
I think you may have missed the bit that says 'REST OF TRANSCRIPTION COMING SOON' only the start and end of it is there at the moment, waiting for the middle bit from my team. But yes I see how with that bit missing it doesn't explain much at all =D
You need to watch the video for the middle bit though as its quite visual.
Do you mind me asking why you read the transcript instead?
Kim, I think he missed all that bit, no worrys though =D
[Reply]
Good tips.
I know most of the companies do these kind of big mistake.
[Reply]
Matthew Woodward Reply:
November 11th, 2012 at 10:21 am
You wouldn't believe some of the mistakes big corporates make – such as rolling out sitewide noindex tags, letting domains expire, letting ssl certificates expire – all by people that get paid more money than sense.
[Reply]
I really cannot believe that this is the reality!
[Reply]
Matthew Woodward Reply:
November 12th, 2012 at 11:15 am
I could have done a better job with nothing more than my forehead and a keyboard ^^
[Reply]
Colin Williams Reply:
November 12th, 2012 at 12:59 pm
Unfortunately when teams get too big it gets easier for things to fall through the cracks. Unless you have processes or people in place to check things like this its easily done. And things expiring is a common problem especially if the guy that set them up has left and moved on to another job maybe! Shouldnt happen but it does, too often!
[Reply]
Matthew Woodward Reply:
December 31st, 2012 at 1:57 pm
Hi,
That is very true indeed, even the basics of renewing domains and SSL certificates used to fall through the gaps.
Explaining that to a major client was always fun….
[Reply]
Good stuff Matt and pretty typical of what I see with too many business websites. They have the resources but the execution often sucks.
[Reply]
Matthew Woodward Reply:
November 12th, 2012 at 4:08 pm
Very true indeed – thats precisely why I stopped banging my head against the wall of the corporate world and took the jump.
A better landing page would have being 'GET FIBRE NOW' in big letters, a picture of a turd and a buy now button.
Can you imagine what can actually be achieved with budgets like that in that right hands?
[Reply]
In all fairness… their site was not done then…. Try to visit it now and see
When did you upload/create the video? 1-2 weeks ago?
[Reply]
Matthew Woodward Reply:
November 12th, 2012 at 4:04 pm
I first noticed the state of the site on Monday 5th November which is why I placed my order with PlusNet on the 6th November. When I found out PlusNet had lied to me on Saturday the 10th of November I revisited Everything Everywhere and was shocked to see the site still in that state so I had some lunch and then got to work on the video.
The actual issues of the site were recorded between the hours of 14:03 and 14:26 on the 10th of November. You can see a screenshot of my project folder and associated times/dates here http://i.imgur.com/UzP3t.png
AND as a final nail in the coffin, I upgraded my PC and reinstalled from scratch on the afternoon of the 8th (after first noticing the issues, but before revisiting) so was running a fresh install of Windows/Firefox and it STILL had all of those problems.
I didn't include any of that in the video though
I see they have now put in quick/dirty fixes for some of the issues – although there are a fair few I didn't include in the video that persist.
[Reply]
Matthew Woodward Reply:
November 13th, 2012 at 9:26 am
Hi John, updated the post to address your questions directly and remove any wiggle room
[Reply]
John Nre Reply:
November 13th, 2012 at 1:59 pm
Cool… Sent you a PM on BHW btw. Awaiting your reply!
[Reply]
You know, while this may be amazing to some in the industry, it's seemingly becoming more and more common in the marketplace.
In our neck of the woods, the City of Vancouver was recently (August 2012) critiqued about spending upwards of $3M on their website and what in fact was received in return should it be of interest…
http://www.vancitybuzz.com/2012/08/3-million-for-city-of-vancouver-website/
It's interesting to see who is awarded these contracts as well as discovering any pre-established ties or relationships. The code on release looked like… well… sub-standard to put it politely.
Great vid, Matt!
[Reply]
Colin Williams Reply:
November 12th, 2012 at 12:53 pm
If you been in software development for any amount of time, you know its easy to blow 3 million in hardware and development time pretty quickly. Especially if you have little or no experienced project management or technical skills in that area to do QA.
If you dont have the experience to check what your vendor is selling you, its cheaper to hire another company to do it for you…. otherwise you wont get what you pay for!
[Reply]
Matthew Woodward Reply:
November 13th, 2012 at 9:03 am
Jesus, $3 million for that? At least their website works though and doesn't repeatedly highlight their incompetence.
Colin, I know exactly how that goes with my background. I always thought it was hilarious just how much money big corporates would spend on websites which left an awful lot to be desired to say the very least.
[Reply]
DDWM Vancouver Website Design Marketing Reply:
November 13th, 2012 at 1:06 pm
Matt, on launch, problems were analogous to those experienced by EE. In fact, the site was inaccessible for periods, found to be quite slow, and routinely demonstrated broken functionality on initial public release.
Colin Williams, we've worked with ERP implementations of varying shapes and sizes over the years. And while I can appreciate how to some Fortune 500/1000 IT companies, $3M can quickly and easily evaporate thanks to one or two badly-made or misplaced decisions when we're talking about CUSTOM development projects, a quick perusal of the source code reveals a reliance on the RedDot CMS framework (windows based content management application – https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RedDot – acquired by OpenText in 2006 – http://www.opentext.com/2/global/products/products-all/reddot-landing.htm – rebranded in 2009 – http://www.cmswire.com/cms/web-cms/farewell-reddot-viva-open-text-web-solutions-003961.php).
All for using compatible frameworks and RAD solutions when and where applicable. And, yes, some can get quite pricey. However, the framework and (dys)functionality coupled with the release quirks made the associated price tag somewhat less than credible, IMHO. Point of contention for several in the local design and development industry, and a great source of discussions for a couple of weeks here.
Thanks for sharing your views on both… insightful.
[Reply]
Colin Williams Reply:
November 13th, 2012 at 1:25 pm
A big team could easily gobble up that money fast. Still think a better approach to development is to have a really small team of skilled developers that really know whatever platform they are working on backwards and inside out. Yes they may cost you a lot more per person, but because they know exactly how to get the best out of the platform to provide the solution and will generally be more experienced you get a lot more for less in the end
[Reply]
DDWM Vancouver Website Design Marketing Reply:
November 13th, 2012 at 2:52 pm
Colin Williams – "… a better approach to development is to have a really small team of skilled developers that really know whatever platform they are working on backwards and inside out."
BINGO! Lean, mean & agile.
[Reply]
I know it wasn't funny for you wasting 30mins trying to buy from these clowns, but your vid is hilarious!
[Reply]
Matthew Woodward Reply:
November 13th, 2012 at 8:59 am
I bet the person in charge of the project doesn't think so. Ahh well, learn2website!
[Reply]
I love how there's like 600 lines of code before you get to the content
[Reply]
Matthew Woodward Reply:
November 15th, 2012 at 5:30 pm
I dont think that is quite as problematic as it used to be but still, 600 is certainly beyond what I would consider acceptable by a long way
[Reply]
You just reminded me the value of 1 customer by your brief statement there Matthew. Thanks!
[Reply]
Matthew Woodward Reply:
March 19th, 2013 at 9:24 am
Something that big company’s often forget – what do you think I’ve said to anyone thinking about getting a new phone/broadband in the past 4 months ^^
[Reply]